BMW 3-Series E46 Sedan 318 i 143HP manual vs Subaru Legacy III Estate 2.0 125HP manual 4x4

BMW 3-Series E46 Sedan 318 i 143HP manual

Source: wikipedia.org Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported

17 reasons for

BMW 3-Series E46 Sedan, model available from 1998 to 2007.
It has 318 i 143HP petrol engine produced from 2001 to 2005.
Drive on the rear axle has manual, 5 speed gearbox.

10 reasons for

Subaru Legacy III Estate, model available from 1998 to 2003.
It has 2.0 125HP petrol engine produced from 1998 to 2003.
Drive 4x4 has manual, 5 speed gearbox.

Subaru Legacy III Estate 2.0 125HP manual 4x4
BMW

17 reasons for BMW Seria 3 E46 Sedan 318 i 143KM manual in comparison to Subaru Legacy III Estate 2.0 125HP manual 4x4

Reasons for
135

Maximal power

143 > 125 hp
The horsepower is a something that most of us pay the biggest attention to. In this comparison, it is the BMW which has by 18 horsepower more than the Subaru Legacy III Estate, which makes this car slightly faster. With more horsepower the BMW 3-Series E46 will as well give slightly better flexiblility in specific speeds.
112

Average consumption

7 > 9.2 l
The fuel economy is considerably to BMW 3-Series E46's advantage. This vehicle burns 2.2 l fewer gasoline in the mixed cycle in comparison to the Subaru. Bear in mind that average fuel consumption in the combined cycle for the large family cars segment, in which the BMW 3-Series E46 is classified, equals to 7.7 l while the BMW 3-Series E46 Sedan uses by 9 % less fuel than the average.
56

Urban consumption

10.4 > 12.8 l
The BMW 3-Series E46 Sedan 318 i 143HP manual burns up 2.4 l fewer while driving inside city in relation to the Subaru Legacy III Estate 2.0 125HP manual 4x4. The difference at the level of 2.4 l is not perceptible in daily usage of the ride at the same time during the term of a several months it would give a substantial cost reduction.
50

Acceleration 0-100 km/h

9.3 > 11.1 s
A little difference that amounts to 16 percent suggests that the Subaru is the worst vehicle of these two . In the „D segment, being represented by the Subaru, the medium acceleration to 100km/h is 9.9 s and is by 1.2 s higher than this of Subaru car.
33

Top speed

218 > 185 km/h
The maximum speed of the BMW 3-Series E46 is higher as compared to this of the Subaru Legacy III Estate 2.0 125HP manual 4x4 which allows to travel the same distance on the highway in shorter period of time. The difference at the level of 33 kilometers per hour is not big and is imperceptible in daily use.
22

Width

1,739 > 1,694 mm
The width of the vehicle influences on passanger's inner room as well as driving stability. The BMW 3-Series E46 Sedan 318 i 143HP manual is 45 mm wider in comparison to the Subaru Legacy III Estate 2.0 125HP manual 4x4. It is clearly perceptible by those sitting in front, who have more room for their elbows.
19

Range

875 > 681 km
15

Wheelbase

2,720 > 2,652 mm
The wheelbase of a vehicle means the length separating its front and rear wheels. The wheelbase significantly affects the driving due to more desirable car's weight distribution. BMW 3-Series E46 Sedan 318 i 143HP manual has 68 millimeters longer wheelbase distance when compared to Subaru Legacy III. Wheelbase dimensions are important to the balance and steering. Hence, the mass of BMW 3-Series E46 Sedan should be better distributed and driving should be easier and safer.
12

Urban range

618 > 500 km
8

Maximum load capacity

500 > 445 kg
4

Rear track

1,478 > 1,455 mm
3

Price range

luxury > popular
1

Tire width

205 > 195 mm
0

Front track

1,471 > 1,457 mm
0

End of model sale

2007 > 2003
0

Tire diameter

16 > 15 ″
0

Tire profile

55 > 60 %

Subaru

10 reasons for Subaru Legacy III Kombi 2.0 125KM manual 4x4 in comparison to BMW 3-Series E46 Sedan 318 i 143HP manual

Reasons for
38

Trunk capacity

529 > 399 l
The Subaru Legacy III Estate features 130 l larger luggage compartment than the BMW 3-Series E46 Sedan. Such a difference is quite relevant and it will matters when it comes to the comfort of the vehicle’s usage. It is worth to note that the Subaru Legacy III Estate 2.0 125HP manual 4x4 has 68 liters bigger boot size than the average in its class. Roomy trunk will be useful during family traveling as well as while daily driving.
19

Fuel tank

65 > 62 l
The winner of this comparison in the aspect of fuel tank size is Subaru Legacy III Estate that is able to hold by 5 % more gasoline in comparison to the BMW.
8

Engine capacity

1,995 > 1,994 cc
The Subaru Legacy III Estate 2.0 125HP manual 4x4 has 1 cc larger engine capacity in comparison to the BMW 3-Series E46. Because the difference is not big, the Subaru should accelerate only slightly dynamically, of course assuming that other paramerters are does not play a role.
6

Length

4,680 > 4,492 mm
The Subaru Legacy III Estate is 4 % longer when compared to the BMW 3-Series E46 Sedan 318 i 143HP manual. The length of the car is significant in terms of travelling comfort and space in the trunk. The Subaru Legacy III Estate 2.0 125HP manual 4x4 probably will be offering to it's passangers more room for legs. Aditionally the Subaru will be better driven but the BMW will be a slightly easier to park due to shorter length of the body.
4

Cylinder layout

boxer > inline
A Boxer engine installed in the Subaru Legacy III is significantly better because it is smaller and generates less vibrations compared to engine with cylinders arranged in a straight line. Additionally it is worth knowing its flat configuration results in that a vehicle has a lower center of gravity what affects the better grip. The advantage of In-line engine, like the one placed inside the BMW, is that because of its simplicity of construction it can be fuel efficient compared to other types of engines.
3

Number of doors

5 > 4
A five-door car usually is a hatchback (however estate cars also count as 5-door cars) and as a result the Subaru Legacy III Estate, which whole rear including the window lifts up and the rear seats folds flat giving more space for cargo, has the edge over the four-door BMW 3-Series E46 Sedan with the hinges for the boot that opens under the rear window.
1

Height

1,516 > 1,367 mm
If you are a tall driver or you carry in the trunk stuffs of big dimensions, the Subaru Legacy III Estate, which is by 11 percent higher than the BMW, is appropriate option for you. However, presented vehicles do not differ much in its height and it should not be much noticeable.
0

Maximal power RPM

5,600 > 6,000 revolutions/minute
0

Payload

1,890 > 1,820 kg
0

Curb weight

1,445 > 1,315 kg

Cars specifications

BMW 3-Series E46 Sedan 318 i 143HP manual Subaru Legacy III Estate 2.0 125HP manual 4x4
    Price range luxury popular
    Model release date 1998 1998
    Facelifting no no
    Code name E46 -
    Class D D
By using this site, you agree to the storage and use of cookie files. OK