BMW 5-Series F10 Limousine F10 520d 184HP manual vs Jaguar XF Sedan 3.0 V6 238HP automatic

BMW 5-Series F10 Limousine F10 520d 184HP manual

Source: wikipedia.org OSX All Rights Released into the public domain

15 reasons for

BMW 5-Series F10 Limousine F10, model available from 2010.
It has 520d 184HP diesel engine produced from 2010.
Drive on the rear axle has manual, 6 speed gearbox.

12 reasons for

Jaguar XF Sedan, model available from 2008.
It has 3.0 V6 238HP ic petrol engine produced from 2008 to 2011.
Drive has automatic, 6 speed gearbox.

Jaguar XF Sedan 3.0 V6 238HP automatic
BMW

15 reasons for BMW Seria 5 F10 Limuzyna F10 520d 184KM manual in comparison to Jaguar XF Sedan 3.0 V6 238HP automatic

Reasons for
112

Average consumption

4.8 > 10.5 l
As opposed to the Jaguar XF Sedan 3.0 V6 238HP automatic, the fuel economy of BMW 5-Series F10 is really attractive. The BMW consumes 5.7 L/100Km fewer fuel in relation to the Jaguar XF Sedan.
59

Maximal torque

381 > 291 Nm
Because of 31 % more torque, the engine of the BMW 5-Series F10 distinctly better transmits power to the wheels than the Jaguar XF. This, in turn, have a positive impact on a car's acceleration.
56

Urban consumption

6 > 15.8 l
The BMW burns up of 62 % diesel fewer in city traffic in comparison to the Jaguar XF. The BMW 5-Series F10, as a representative of E class, uses 5.9 l of fuel for every 100 km fewer than the average in its class. The average fuel consumption in the “executive” segment equals to 11.9 l per 100 km.
50

Acceleration 0-100 km/h

8.1 > 8.3 s
The BMW 5-Series F10 can reach the speed of 100Km/h in 8.1 s, which is 0.2 s faster in comparison to the Jaguar XF. However the difference is not as much big to be taken into account when buying a automobile.
30

Maximal torque RPM

1,905 > 4,100 revolutions/minute
This big difference results from the fact that both vehicles are equipped with various engines. The BMW 5-Series F10 Limousine F10 is equipped with the diesel engine whereas the Jaguar XF has the petrol engine. Taking into consideration different types of engines, comparing this characteristic seems to be pointless.
24

Extra-urban consumption

4.3 > 7.7 l
15

Wheelbase

2,975 > 2,900 mm
The BMW 5-Series F10 Limousine F10 has 75 mm longer wheelbase than Jaguar XF. As a result the BMW 5-Series F10 is safer and has a better stability. Moreover, longer wheelbase influences on convenient and more comfortable driving.
8

Maximum load capacity

535 > 525 kg
4

Rear track

1,627 > 1,572 mm
1

Model release date

2010 > 2008
The difference in date of commencement of production between presented cars is only 2 years, however, new technologies for automotive industry are appearing at a fast pace and for that reason the BMW 5-Series F10 may have more advanced solutions.
1

Height

1,474 > 1,458 mm
The higher a car is, the the more convenient is a getting in to it and greater capacity of loading massive amount of luggage to it. The difference between these two cars that amounts to 1 % to the advantage of the BMW 5-Series F10 is little and does not matter much.
0

Maximal power RPM

4,000 > 6,800 revolutions/minute
0

Payload

2,250 > 2,220 kg
0

Front track

1,602 > 1,559 mm
0

Curb weight

1,713 > 1,694 kg

Jaguar

12 reasons for Jaguar XF Sedan 3.0 V6 238KM automat in comparison to BMW 5-Series F10 Limousine F10 520d 184HP manual

Reasons for
135

Maximal power

238 > 184 hp
The Jaguar XF is equipped with petrol which makes by 29 % more horsepower over the the engine of the BMW 5-Series F10, transforming the car to a more sporty character. It seems to be better option to those who want to experience thrill of drive a sports car.
38

Trunk capacity

540 > 520 l
If you are looking for a vehicles by which you could set of for trips, which could hold more luggage , decide to buy the Jaguar XF. The BMW 5-Series F10 has by 4 % smaller luggage compartment in relation to the BMW 5-Series F10 Limousine F10 so in this case you would be able to take with you one small parcel less. Assessing the luggage compartment also pay attention to its dimensions which have appreciable impact on loading possibility .
33

Top speed

237 > 227 km/h
The maximum speed possible to be reached by the Jaguar is higher in comparison to this of the BMW 5-Series F10 Limousine F10 520d 184HP manual which allows to drive the same distance on the highway in shorter period of time. The difference that amounts to 4 percent is not big and is imperceptible in everyday use.
14

Cylinders

6 > 4
8

Engine capacity

2,968 > 1,994 cc
The Jaguar has 49 percent larger cubic capacity when compared to the BMW 5-Series F10 Limousine F10. The difference is large. For this reason the Jaguar XF should accelerate faster and be able to achieve higher maximum speed. On the other hand greater engine displacement usually results in worst fuel consumption.
6

Length

4,964 > 4,889 mm
The Jaguar XF Sedan is 2 percent longer in relation to the BMW 5-Series F10. The length of the car is significant in respect of travelling comfort and room in the trunk. The Jaguar XF Sedan 3.0 V6 238HP automatic very likely will be offering to it's users more space for legs. At the same time the Jaguar XF will be better driven ,however, the BMW will be a slightly easier for parking because of shorter length of the body.
4

Cylinder layout

V-type > inline
An engine in the shape of a V is a better version of a engine with all cylinders aligned in one row which in our opinion} is {a better one. Engine of V characteristic in a the Jaguar XF Sedan 3.0 V6 238HP automatic produces more torque at lower RPM ranges due to the power stroke coming from 2 sides of the crankshaft. This type of engime may house more cylinders in a smaller package. A Better engine work and pleasant sound is to driving fans undoubtedly to a Vee engine’s advantage.
1

Tire width

245 > 225 mm
0

Transmission

automatic > manual
Automatic transmission installed in the Jaguar XF Sedan 3.0 V6 238HP automatic despite having a few drawback offers much more better comfort of driving. After a long time spent at the steering wheel you probably would be less exhausted. Moreover automatic puts less strain on the engine because of the factory settings of changing gears in specific revs range.
0

Valves

24 > 16
0

Tire diameter

18 > 17 ″
0

Tire profile

45 > 55 %

Cars specifications

BMW 5-Series F10 Limousine F10 520d 184HP manual Jaguar XF Sedan 3.0 V6 238HP automatic
    Gross trailer weight 2,005 kg -
    Price range luxury luxury
    Model release date 2010 2008
    Facelifting no no
    Code name F10-F11 -
By using this site, you agree to the storage and use of cookie files. OK