BMW X1 Crossover sDrive20i 184HP automatic vs Opel Astra H GTC 2.0 Turbo ECOTEC OPC 240HP manual

BMW X1 Crossover sDrive20i 184HP automatic

Source: wikipedia.org M 93 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Germany

23 reasons for

BMW X1 Crossover, model available from 2009.
It has sDrive20i 184HP ic petrol engine produced from 2011 to 2012.
Drive on the rear axle has automatic gearbox.

7 reasons for

Opel Astra H GTC, model available from 2004.
It has 2.0 Turbo ECOTEC OPC 240HP petrol engine produced from 2005 to 2011.
Drive on the front axle has manual, 6 speed gearbox.

Opel Astra H GTC 2.0 Turbo ECOTEC OPC 240HP manual
BMW

23 reasons for BMW X1 Crossover sDrive20i 184KM automat in comparison to Opel Astra H GTC 2.0 Turbo ECOTEC OPC 240HP manual

Reasons for
112

Average consumption

6.6 > 9.2 l
The BMW X1 uses 28 % fewer fuel in the mixed cycle in relation to the Opel Astra H GTC. The difference at the level of 2.6 l will be realy noticeable in everyday usage of the vehicle. In the long term it will result in a real savings.
56

Urban consumption

9 > 12.9 l
The fuel consumption while driving inside city is distinctly to the BMW X1's advantage. This automobile uses 30 % less petrol in built up area than the Opel Astra H GTC 2.0 Turbo ECOTEC OPC 240HP manual. Better fuel consumption equals less fuel cost passed on you.
38

Trunk capacity

420 > 342 l
The BMW X1 Crossover sDrive20i 184HP automatic has 78 liters larger trunk compared with the Opel Astra H GTC 2.0 Turbo ECOTEC OPC 240HP manual. Such a difference is big and it will affect the comfort of the car’s usage. It is worth to note that the BMW X1 Crossover has 6 percent bigger trunk capacity than the average in its class. Bigger trunk will be useful during family journeys and also during everyday car’s usage.
33

Trunk capacity with seats down

1,349 > 1,328 l
30

Maximal torque RPM

1,255 > 2,400 revolutions/minute
The RMP where the maximum torque is produced indicates how fast an engine reaches its best output with increase in rmp. The lower revolutions or the wider range at which the torque is the greatest, the more the engine is flexible and the kick of acceleration should be felt faster.
24

Extra-urban consumption

5.2 > 7.2 l
22

Width

1,796 > 1,756 mm
Distance between two sides of a vehicle directly affects the amount of space for passengers and also stability during driving. The width of the BMW X1 Crossover sDrive20i 184HP automatic is larger by 2 % compared with the Opel Astra H GTC 2.0 Turbo ECOTEC OPC 240HP manual and is not really worth considering. The medium for the „compact SUV” segment amounts to around 1,797 mm and is by 1 mm smaller than the same feature of the BMW X1 Crossover.
19

Range

926 > 565 km
19

Fuel tank

62 > 52 l
In this category it is the BMW that can carry 10 liters more fuel compared with the Opel Astra H. The medium fuel container size in the mini 4x4 segment, from which the BMW X1 comes from, amounts to 61 liters, whereas in small family cars class (represented by the Opel Astra H) it is 52 liters.
15

Wheelbase

2,760 > 2,614 mm
BMW has 6 percent longer wheelbase than the Opel Astra H GTC. A longer wheelbase gives more stable and comfortable ride, especially when driving fast. It also gives more storage space. But, vehicles with a longer wheelbase will not be as maneuverable as those with a shorter length between its axles.
12

Urban range

716 > 400 km
11

Extra-urban range

1,189 > 743 km
6

Length

4,454 > 4,288 mm
The BMW is 166 mm longer in comparison to the Opel Astra H. The length of the vehicle is important in respect of driving comfort and room in the boot. The BMW X1 Crossover sDrive20i 184HP automatic preasumbly will be offering to it's passangers more space for legs. Aditionally the BMW will be better driven ,however, the Opel Astra H will be a little easier for parking due to shorter length .
4

Rear track

1,529 > 1,491 mm
3

Number of doors

5 > 3
There’s no doubts that the five-door BMW X1 Crossover is more convenient and if you regularly drive with more than one passenger then you should not have any doubts which one to choose. The strongest point of a five-door vehicle is that it’s not only easier for passengers to climb into the rear seats but it’s as well easier to place luggage and cargo into the car when the rear seats are folded down. However, three-door cars like the Opel Astra H very often look more dynamic and sporty and for young drivers who don’t often have passengers in the back seat the Opel Astra H GTC 2.0 Turbo ECOTEC OPC 240HP manual might be more appropriate.
3

Price range

luxury > popular
1

Model release date

2009 > 2004
The difference in debut day between these two cars is only 5 years, however, new technologies for vehicles are appearing at a blistering pace what may cause that the BMW may have more modern solutions.
1

Height

1,545 > 1,413 mm
If you are a tall driver or you tend to carry in the trunk thinks of big dimensions, the BMW, which is by 9 percent higher than the Opel Astra H GTC, is appropriate pick for you. However, these two vehicles do not differ much when it comes to its height and it should not be much observable.
0

Transmission

automatic > manual
Automatic gearbox which is in the BMW X1 despite having a few disadvantages offers much more better comfort of driving. After a long time spent at the steering wheel you probably would be less tired. Moreover automatic puts less strain on the engine thanks to the factory settings of shifts in specific revs range.
0

Maximal power RPM

5,000 > 5,600 revolutions/minute
0

Front track

1,498 > 1,490 mm
0

Width with outside mirrors

2,049 > 2,031 mm
0

Curb weight

1,584 > 1,395 kg

Opel

7 reasons for Opel Astra H GTC 2.0 Turbo ECOTEC OPC 240KM manual in comparison to BMW X1 Crossover sDrive20i 184HP automatic

Reasons for
135

Maximal power

240 > 184 hp
The Opel Astra H comes with petrol which delivers by 30 percent more horsepower over the BMW X1 Crossover sDrive20i 184HP automatic, transforming the car to a more sporty character. It seems to be googd car for drivers who would like to experience thrill of getting behind the wheel of a sports car.
59

Maximal torque

320 > 271 Nm
Maximum torque of the Opel is 18 % greater than the BMW X1 Crossover. Because of this, the Opel Astra H will accelerate somewhat better and be better for overtaking other cars. Appropriate use of the flexibility of the engine may also cause that the Opel Astra H will burn up less fuel per 100 kilometers.
50

Acceleration 0-100 km/h

6.4 > 7.7 s
The Opel Astra H GTC 2.0 Turbo ECOTEC OPC 240HP manual accelerates from 0 to 100 Km/h in 6.4 s, which is 17 % less than the BMW X1. However the difference is not as much significant to be taken into consideration when buying a vehicle.
33

Top speed

244 > 220 km/h
The maximum speed possible to be reached by the Opel Astra H GTC is higher in comparison to this of the BMW X1 Crossover sDrive20i 184HP automatic which allows to cover the same distance on the highway in shorter period of time. The difference at the level of 24 kilometers/hour is not big and is imperceptible in everyday driving.
8

Engine capacity

1,999 > 1,996 cc
The Opel Astra H GTC has 3 cc bigger engine capacity in relation to the BMW X1 Crossover. Because the difference is little, the Opel Astra H GTC 2.0 Turbo ECOTEC OPC 240HP manual should accelerate slightly dynamically, assuming that other paramerters are equal.
0

Tire diameter

18 > 17 ″
0

Tire profile

40 > 50 %

Cars specifications

BMW X1 Crossover sDrive20i 184HP automatic Opel Astra H GTC 2.0 Turbo ECOTEC OPC 240HP manual
    Price range luxury popular
    Model release date 2009 2004
    Facelifting no no
    Code name - H
    Class compact SUV C
By using this site, you agree to the storage and use of cookie files. OK