Renault Scenic III Grand 1.4 TCe 16v 130HP manual vs Kia Carens II 2.0 CRDi 112HP manual

Renault Scenic III Grand 1.4 TCe 16v 130HP manual

Source: wikipedia.org M 93 All Rights Released

22 reasons for

Renault Scenic III Grand, model available from 2009 to 2013.
It has 1.4 TCe 16v 130HP petrol engine produced from 2009 to 2011.
Drive on the front axle has manual, 6 speed gearbox.

10 reasons for

Kia Carens II, model available from 2002 to 2006.
It has 2.0 CRDi 112HP diesel engine produced from 2002 to 2006.
Drive on the front axle has manual, 5 speed gearbox.

Kia Carens II 2.0 CRDi 112HP manual
Renault

22 reasons for Renault Scenic III Grand 1.4 TCe 16v 130KM manual in comparison to Kia Carens II 2.0 CRDi 112HP manual

Reasons for
135

Maximal power

130 > 112 hp
The horsepower of the Renault Scenic III Grand 1.4 TCe 16v 130HP manual is 18 hp bigger than the Kia Carens II. Because the difference is little this should not affect the car performance to a large extent.
50

Acceleration 0-100 km/h

10.7 > 13.5 s
A little difference that amounts to 2.8 s suggests that the Kia Carens II is the worst car of these two compared. In the „minivan segment, being represented by the Kia Carens II, the medium acceleration amounts to 11.7 s and is by 1.8 s higher than this of Kia car.
38

Trunk capacity

704 > 422 l
With more boot size the Renault will have much more room for transporting things and be more functional one than the Kia Carens II 2.0 CRDi 112HP manual. If the capacity of the trunk is what does appeal to you, the Renault Scenic III will be better choice because it is about 67 percent larger than the trunk of its contender.
33

Trunk capacity with seats down

1,863 > 1,632 l
33

Top speed

190 > 172 km/h
The top velocity of the Renault is higher as compared to this of the Kia which allows to drive the same distance on the highway faster. The difference that amounts to 10 percent is little and is not realy noticable in everyday use.
22

Width

1,840 > 1,744 mm
The width of the car influences directly on passanger's inner room and driving stability. The Renault Scenic III Grand is 6 percent wider in comparison to the Kia Carens II 2.0 CRDi 112HP manual. It is clearly perceptible by those sitting in front, who have more room for their elbows.
19

Range

822 > 786 km
19

Fuel tank

61 > 54 l
In the aspect of fuel tank size it is the Renault Scenic III that can hold 13 percent more fuel in relation to the Kia. The average fuel container capacity in the minivan class, which is represented by the Renault Scenic III, equals 57 liters, whereas in minivan class (represented by the Kia Carens II) it amounts to 57 liters.
15

Wheelbase

2,780 > 2,560 mm
Renault has 9 % longer wheelbase than the Kia Carens II. A longer wheelbase gives more stable and comfortable ride, especially when driving fast. It also gives more storage space. But, cars with a longer wheelbase are not as maneuverable as those with a shorter wheelbase.
12

Urban range

612 > 573 km
10

Number of gears

6 > 5 gears
The Renault Scenic III Grand have a higher gear count compared with the Kia Carens II which means that Renault Scenic III Grand will achieve better acceleration and better fuel economy. But the difference is not big and unless you are drag racing at a timed event you would not even observe the difference.
8

Maximum load capacity

660 > 516 kg
6

Length

4,565 > 4,489 mm
The Renault Scenic III Grand 1.4 TCe 16v 130HP manual is 2 percent longer than the Kia. The length of the car is significant in terms of travelling comfort and room in the trunk. The Renault preasumbly will be offering to it's users more space for legs. Aditionally the Renault Scenic III Grand 1.4 TCe 16v 130HP manual will be better driven but the Kia will be a slightly easier to park because of shorter length of the body.
4

Rear track

1,538 > 1,483 mm
1

Model release date

2009 > 2002
Manufacture of the older vehicle began 7 years prior to its rival and for this reason we may expect that this vehicle is equipped with not so modern solutions applied.
1

Height

1,645 > 1,611 mm
If you are a tall man or you tend to carry in the trunk thinks of large dimensions, the Renault, which is by 34 millimeters higher than the Kia, is appropriate pick for you. However, compared vehicles do not differ much in its height and it should not be much perceptible.
0

Payload

2,084 > 1,965 kg
0

Front track

1,536 > 1,490 mm
0

End of model sale

2013 > 2006
0

Front overhang

885 > 919 mm
0

Tire diameter

16 > 15 ″
0

Rear overhang

906 > 1,018 mm

Kia

10 reasons for Kia Carens II 2.0 CRDi 112KM manual in comparison to Renault Scenic III Grand 1.4 TCe 16v 130HP manual

Reasons for
112

Average consumption

7.2 > 7.5 l
The Kia Carens II consumes 4 percent less in the combined cycle in relation to the Renault Scenic III Grand. The difference at the level of 0.3 l is not significant. Nevertheless during a longer period of time it would allow you to make a considerable reduction of costs.
59

Maximal torque

246 > 190 Nm
The Kia Carens II has 56 newton meters more torque in comparison to the Renault Scenic III. The difference at this level is relevant, so that the Kia Carens II will be seeding up perceptibly faster.
56

Urban consumption

9.6 > 9.8 l
The Kia Carens II burns up 2 percent less petrol in the city compared to the Renault Scenic III Grand. The Kia Carens II, that represents minivan class, uses 1.4 l fewer fuel. Keep in mind that average fuel consumption in the urban for the minivan segment equals to 8.2 l, whereas the Kia consumes by 18 percent more fuel than the average.
30

Maximal torque RPM

1,995 > 2,250 revolutions/minute
A greater range and a lower number of revolutions at which the maximum torque is delivered affects an engine’s efficiency and flexibility. However, to eliminate engines drawbacks like e.g. turbo lug, it is always worth to analyze a torque performance graph.
24

Extra-urban consumption

5.4 > 5.9 l
11

Extra-urban range

1,019 > 1,017 km
8

Engine capacity

1,990 > 1,398 cc
The Kia Carens II has 592 cc bigger engine capacity in relation to the Renault. The difference is relatively notable. Consequently the Kia Carens II should accelerate faster and be able to achieve higher top speed. On the other hand larger engine size usually results in worst fuel economy.
0

Maximal power RPM

4,000 > 5,500 revolutions/minute
0

Number of seats

7 > 5
0

Curb weight

1,450 > 1,419 kg

Cars specifications

Renault Scenic III Grand 1.4 TCe 16v 130HP manual Kia Carens II 2.0 CRDi 112HP manual
    Gross trailer weight 1,296 kg -
    Price range popular popular
    Model release date 2009 2002
    Facelifting no no
    Class minivan minivan
By using this site, you agree to the storage and use of cookie files. OK