Kia Carens III 2.0 i 16V 144HP manual vs Renault Scenic I Minivan 1.9 dTi 80HP manual

Kia Carens III 2.0 i 16V 144HP manual

Source: wikipedia.org Thomas doerfer Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0

19 reasons for

Kia Carens III, model available from 2006 to 2012.
It has 2.0 i 16V 144HP petrol engine produced from 2006 to 2010.
Drive on the front axle has manual, 5 speed gearbox.

12 reasons for

Renault Scenic I Minivan, model available from 1996 to 2003.
It has 1.9 dTi 80HP diesel engine produced from 2000 to 2003.
Drive on the front axle has manual, 5 speed gearbox.

Renault Scenic I Minivan 1.9 dTi 80HP manual
Kia

19 reasons for Kia Carens III 2.0 i 16V 144KM manual in comparison to Renault Scenic I Minivan 1.9 dTi 80HP manual

Reasons for
135

Maximal power

144 > 80 hp
The horsepower is a feature that most of car fans look at first when buying a car. In this comparison it is the Kia that has by 64 more horsepower in comparison to the Renault Scenic I. Therefore the Kia Carens III is able to reach higher speed. Having more horsepower the Kia will also give more flexiblility in specific speeds.
59

Maximal torque

190 > 160 Nm
The Kia Carens III has 30 newton meters more torque than the Renault Scenic I Minivan 1.9 dTi 80HP manual. Even though the majority of people do not take into account the maximum torque when buying a car, it describes the best how a vehicle is speeding up. As far as these two vehicles are concerned the difference is insensible so it probably will not make a real difference in feeling of driving a car.
50

Acceleration 0-100 km/h

11 > 15.7 s
If a dynamic driving is what you are really in to, the Kia Carens III will appeal to you because it’s acceleration to 100 km/h is 4.7 s faster compared to the Renault Scenic I Minivan 1.9 dTi 80HP manual.
38

Trunk capacity

430 > 412 l
The trunk of the Kia is only 4 % bigger than the Renault Scenic I Minivan 1.9 dTi 80HP manual. However, the difference is so little that it would be fair to say that both cars have more of less the same boot size.
33

Top speed

190 > 162 km/h
The maximum velocity of the ​​Kia Carens III is greater compared with the Renault Scenic I Minivan 1.9 dTi 80HP manual by 28 kilometers per hour, which allows the Kia Carens III to overcome quicker large distance of highway. The difference at the level of 28 kilometers/hour is little and will not be a very noticable in everyday driving.
22

Width

1,820 > 1,719 mm
The width of the vehicle influences on passanger's inner room as well as driving stability. The Kia Carens III is 101 mm wider in relation to the Renault. It is often clearly felt by driver and passenger in front, who have more room for their elbows.
15

Wheelbase

2,697 > 2,586 mm
The wheelbase of a vehicle is the distance between its front and rear wheels. The wheelbase notably affects the driving because of better car's weight distribution. Kia Carens III has 4 % longer wheelbase distance in comparison to Renault Scenic I Minivan 1.9 dTi 80HP manual. Wheelbase dimensions are important to the stability and steering. Hence, the mass of Kia Carens III should be better distributed and driving should be easier and safer.
8

Engine capacity

1,997 > 1,871 cc
The Kia Carens III has by 126 cc bigger engine displacement in relation to the Renault. This play a little role when it comes to car's performance, as both figures are quite simmilar.
8

Maximum load capacity

686 > 575 kg
6

Length

4,545 > 4,169 mm
The Kia is 9 % longer in relation to the Renault Scenic I Minivan 1.9 dTi 80HP manual. The length of the car is important in terms of driving comfort and room in the boot. The Kia Carens III probably will be offering to it's passangers more space for legs. Aditionally the Kia will be better driven but the Renault Scenic I will be a bit easier to park due to shorter length of the body.
4

Rear track

1,569 > 1,485 mm
1

Model release date

2006 > 1996
Manufacture of the older car started 10 years prior to Renault Scenic I hence we may expect that this car features not so advanced parts .
1

Tire width

205 > 185 mm
0

Payload

2,106 > 1,835 kg
0

Front track

1,573 > 1,451 mm
0

Valves per cylinder

4 > 2
0

End of model sale

2012 > 2003
0

Valves

16 > 8
0

Curb weight

1,417 > 1,268 kg

Renault

12 reasons for Renault Scenic I Minivan 1.9 dTi 80KM manual in comparison to Kia Carens III 2.0 i 16V 144HP manual

Reasons for
112

Average consumption

5.9 > 8.6 l
The fuel economy is distinctly to Renault Scenic I Minivan's advantage. This car uses 31 percent fewer diesel in the combined cycle in relation to the Kia Carens III 2.0 i 16V 144HP manual. Keep in mind that average fuel consumption in the combined cycle for the minivan segment, in which the Renault is classified, is 6.5 l while the Renault needs by 9 percent less amount of fuel than the average.
56

Urban consumption

7.3 > 11.1 l
The fuel economy running around the town is distinctly to the Renault's advantage. This car consumes 34 percent fewer diesel in built up area in relation to the Kia Carens III. Better fuel consumption equals less fuel cost passed on you.
33

Trunk capacity with seats down

1,798 > 76 l
30

Maximal torque RPM

2,000 > 4,245 revolutions/minute
Such a huge difference results from the fact that both compared cars have different engines. The Renault Scenic I is equipped with the diesel engine and the Kia Carens III 2.0 i 16V 144HP manual has the petrol engine. Taking into consideration different types of engines, comparing this characteristic seems to be pointless.
24

Extra-urban consumption

4.8 > 6.9 l
19

Fuel tank

61 > 54 l
The Kia Carens III 2.0 i 16V 144HP manual loses with the Renault Scenic I in the category of fuel tank size. The Renault Scenic I Minivan is able to take by 13 percent more fuel than its rival.
19

Range

1,053 > 655 km
12

Urban range

822 > 495 km
11

Extra-urban range

1,250 > 797 km
0

Maximal power RPM

4,000 > 6,000 revolutions/minute
0

Front overhang

840 > 935 mm
0

Rear overhang

710 > 911 mm

Cars specifications

Kia Carens III 2.0 i 16V 144HP manual Renault Scenic I Minivan 1.9 dTi 80HP manual
    Price range popular popular
    Model release date 2006 1996
    Facelifting no no
    Class minivan minivan
    Payload 2,106 kg 1,835 kg
By using this site, you agree to the storage and use of cookie files. OK