Kia Carens IV 1.6 GDI 135HP manual vs Renault Scenic III Van 1.4 TCe 16v 130HP manual

Kia Carens IV 1.6 GDI 135HP manual

Source: wikipedia.org Thesupermat Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0

17 reasons for

Kia Carens IV, model available from 2013.
It has 1.6 GDI 135HP petrol engine produced from 2013.
Drive on the front axle has manual, 6 speed gearbox.

8 reasons for

Renault Scenic III Van, model available from 2009 to 2013.
It has 1.4 TCe 16v 130HP petrol engine produced from 2009 to 2011.
Drive on the front axle has manual, 6 speed gearbox.

Renault Scenic III Van 1.4 TCe 16v 130HP manual
Kia

17 reasons for Kia Carens IV 1.6 GDI 135KM manual in comparison to Renault Scenic III Van 1.4 TCe 16v 130HP manual

Reasons for
135

Maximal power

135 > 130 hp
The horsepower is a parameter that majority of car fans pay the biggest attention to. In this case, it is the Kia Carens IV that has by 4 percent horsepower more in relation to the Renault Scenic III Van, which makes this car a bit better in terms of high speed. Thanks to more horsepower the Kia Carens IV 1.6 GDI 135HP manual will also give somewhat more flexiblility in specific gears.
112

Average consumption

7 > 7.5 l
The Kia consumes 0.5 l fewer in the combined cycle in comparison to the Renault Scenic III Van 1.4 TCe 16v 130HP manual. The difference at the level of 0.5 l is not realy noticeable. However within some time it would allow you to make a real savings.
56

Urban consumption

9 > 9.8 l
The Kia Carens IV uses 8 percent less fuel in city traffic than the Renault Scenic III Van. The Kia Carens IV, that represents minivan segment, uses 0.8 l fewer gasoline. Bear in mind that average fuel consumption in the urban for the minivan segment equals to 8.2 l, whereas the Kia consumes by 10 % more fuel than the average.
38

Trunk capacity

536 > 439 l
With more luggage capacity the Kia Carens IV will have much more room for loading things and be more functional car than the Renault Scenic III Van. If the capacity of the trunk is important to you, the Kia Carens IV will be better to buy because it is about 97 liters more spacious than the trunk of its contender.
24

Extra-urban consumption

5.6 > 5.9 l
15

Wheelbase

2,754 > 2,712 mm
The wheelbase of a vehicle means the distance separating its front and rear wheels. The wheelbase significantly affects the driving due to better vehicle's weight distribution. Kia Carens IV has 42 millimeters longer wheelbase distance than Renault Scenic III. Wheelbase dimensions are important to the balance and steering. Thus, the mass of Kia Carens IV should be better distributed and driving should be easier and safer.
8

Engine capacity

1,590 > 1,398 cc
The Kia Carens IV has by 14 % bigger engine displacement in relation to the Renault Scenic III Van. This may have a little impact as far as acceleration is concerned, as both figures does not differ much.
8

Maximum load capacity

615 > 574 kg
8

Gross trailer weight

1,300 > 1,296 kg
6

Length

4,542 > 4,349 mm
The Kia Carens IV is 193 mm longer when compared to the Renault Scenic III. Long vehicles more of passenger space and in most cases have more storage space. While the Kia Carens IV seems to be better for families or drivers who love the idea of comfortable driving that make them feel fresh and relaxed upon arriving, the Renault Scenic III Van may be more appropriate to the young as it will not make troubles with parking and will be easier for turning in narrow streets.
4

Rear track

1,585 > 1,546 mm
1

Model release date

2013 > 2009
Given that the Renault debuted only 4 years earlier than the Kia, the gap between technology used in both vehicles is not really huge, however, the Kia might have slightly more modern solutions used in it.
1

Height

1,650 > 1,637 mm
If you are a tall driver or you tend to carry in the trunk stuffs of large size, the Kia, which is by 1 percent higher than the Renault Scenic III Van, would be better option for you. However, compared vehicles do not vary much it the aspect of its height and it should not be much noticeable.
0

Payload

1,995 > 1,898 kg
0

Front track

1,573 > 1,545 mm
0

Tire profile

55 > 60 %
0

Curb weight

1,388 > 1,319 kg

Renault

8 reasons for Renault Scenic III Van 1.4 TCe 16v 130KM manual in comparison to Kia Carens IV 1.6 GDI 135HP manual

Reasons for
59

Maximal torque

190 > 166 Nm
Maximum torque of the Renault Scenic III Van 1.4 TCe 16v 130HP manual is 24 Nm bigger than the Kia Carens IV. As a result, the Renault Scenic III Van 1.4 TCe 16v 130HP manual will accelerate somewhat swifter and be better for overtaking other vehicles. Appropriate use of the flexibility of the engine will also make that the Renault Scenic III will use on average fever fuel for every 100 km.
50

Acceleration 0-100 km/h

10.5 > 11.3 s
The Kia speeds up relatively slower in comparison to the Renault Scenic III Van. The difference at the level of 0.8 s is is slightly to the Renault Scenic III Van 1.4 TCe 16v 130HP manual advantage, however, it should not be vitally taken by you into account when choosing one of compared cars.
33

Top speed

190 > 185 km/h
The top speed of the ​​Renault Scenic III Van is greater than this of the Kia Carens IV by 5 km/h, which allows the Renault Scenic III Van 1.4 TCe 16v 130HP manual to travel quicker long distance of highway. The difference at the level of 5 kilometers/hour is small and will be negligible in everyday driving.
30

Maximal torque RPM

2,250 > 4,845 revolutions/minute
A big difference in rpm at which the maximum torque is produced distinctly shows that a car which does not require to be revved high is the one of the Renault Scenic III Van 1.4 TCe 16v 130HP manual. The engine of the Kia reaches its full efficiency at 4,845 revolutions per minute which is by 54 percent worst result than the Renault Scenic III.
22

Width

1,840 > 1,820 mm
The width of the vehicle influences on passanger's inner room as well as driving stability. The Renault is 20 millimeters wider when compared to the Kia Carens IV 1.6 GDI 135HP manual. It is clearly perceptible by those sitting in front, who have more space for their elbows.
0

Maximal power RPM

5,500 > 6,300 revolutions/minute
0

Front overhang

885 > 941 mm
0

Rear overhang

758 > 835 mm

Cars specifications

Kia Carens IV 1.6 GDI 135HP manual Renault Scenic III Van 1.4 TCe 16v 130HP manual
    Gross trailer weight 1,300 kg 1,296 kg
    Price range popular popular
    Model release date 2013 2009
    Facelifting no no
    Class minivan minivan
By using this site, you agree to the storage and use of cookie files. OK