Mercedes E-Class W211 Estate S211 5.0 V8 (500) 306HP automatic vs Renault Vel Satis 2.0 i 16V Turbo 170HP manual

Mercedes E-Class W211 Estate S211 5.0 V8 (500) 306HP automatic

Source: wikipedia.org Matthias93 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported

23 reasons for

Mercedes E-Class W211 Estate S211, model available from 2002 to 2009.
It has 5.0 V8 (500) 306HP ic petrol engine produced from 2003 to 2006.
Drive on the rear axle has automatic, 7 speed gearbox.

15 reasons for

Renault Vel Satis, model available from 2002 to 2009.
It has 2.0 i 16V Turbo 170HP petrol engine produced from 2005 to 2009.
Drive on the front axle has manual, 6 speed gearbox.

Renault Vel Satis 2.0 i 16V Turbo 170HP manual
Mercedes

23 reasons for Mercedes Klasa E W211 Kombi S211 5.0 V8 (500) 306KM automat in comparison to Renault Vel Satis 2.0 i 16V Turbo 170HP manual

Reasons for
135

Maximal power

306 > 170 hp
The Mercedes has by 136 horsepowers more horsepower than Renault Vel Satis. The Mercedes E-Class W211 Estate S211 will be distinctly quicker speed up thanks to bigger horsepower. Also maneuvers like overtaking and passing obstacles like TIRs or buses while moving along the road should be a piece of cake for a vehicle equipped with more powerful motor.
59

Maximal torque

462 > 270 Nm
The Mercedes E-Class W211 Estate S211 has 192 newton meters more torque than the Renault Vel Satis. The difference at such level is relevant, so that the Mercedes E-Class W211 will be seeding up significantly better.
50

Acceleration 0-100 km/h

6.5 > 9.4 s
If a fast driving is what you are keen on, the Mercedes E-Class W211 Estate S211 will appeal to you as it’s acceleration to 100 km/h is 31 % faster compared to the Renault Vel Satis 2.0 i 16V Turbo 170HP manual.
38

Trunk capacity

692 > 452 l
The Mercedes E-Class W211 Estate S211 5.0 V8 (500) 306HP automatic features 240 l larger boot in relation to the Renault Vel Satis. Such a difference is relevant therefore it will distinctly affect the comfort of the car’s usage. It is worth to note that the Mercedes E-Class W211 Estate S211 5.0 V8 (500) 306HP automatic has 198 l bigger trunk size than the average in its segment. Roomy boot will be useful during family journeys as well as while everyday driving.
33

Top speed

250 > 211 km/h
The top speed possible to be reached by the ​​Mercedes is greater compared with the Renault Vel Satis by 18, which allows the Mercedes to cover faster long distance of highway. The difference at the level of 18 percent is little and will be insignificant in everyday driving.
30

Maximal torque RPM

2,695 > 3,250 revolutions/minute
The RMP at which the maximum torque is produced determines how fast an engine reaches its full efficiency with increase in rmp. The lower rmp or the longer range in which the torque is the greatest, the more the engine is flexible and the kick of acceleration should be felt earlier.
15

Wheelbase

2,854 > 2,845 mm
The wheelbase of a car means the distance between its front and rear wheels. The wheelbase significantly affects the driving because of better car's weight distribution. Mercedes has 9 mm longer wheelbase distance than Renault Vel Satis. Wheelbase dimensions are crucial to the stability and steering. Thus, the mass of Mercedes E-Class W211 should be better distributed and driving should be easier and safer.
14

Cylinders

8 > 4
10

Number of gears

7 > 6 gears
The Mercedes E-Class W211 has a one more speed than the Renault Vel Satis. Generally the additional speed is a very tall one thanks to which the previous speeds can be shorter to give increased performance in the lower speeds. One more speed also helps to decrease fuel consumption and CO2 emission.
8

Engine capacity

4,966 > 1,999 cc
Naturally the Mercedes E-Class W211 wins in this category. The difference at the level of 2,967 cc than the Renault Vel Satis 2.0 i 16V Turbo 170HP manual. It is interesting that in „upper middle” segment, from which the Mercedes E-Class W211 Estate S211 5.0 V8 (500) 306HP automatic comes from, the average cubic capacity is 2,659 cc and the biggest engine capacity in this class is 7,443 .
8

Maximum load capacity

575 > 550 kg
4

Cylinder layout

V-type > inline
A V engine is a developed version of a In-line engine which as far as we are concerned is a better choice. Engine of V characteristic installed inside a car the Mercedes E-Class W211 Estate S211 gives more torque at lower RPM ranges because of the power stroke coming from 2 sides of the crankshaft. This type of engime may contain high numbers of cylinders in a smaller package. A Smooth engine work and thrilling sound is undoubtedly to a Vee engine’s advantage.
3

Price range

luxury > popular
1

Tire width

245 > 225 mm
1

Trunk length with seats down

1,835 > 1,702 mm
0

Transmission

automatic > manual
A stick shift with which the Renault Vel Satis 2.0 i 16V Turbo 170HP manual is equipped is more simpler built and is cheaper in use, however, it is less comfortable because the driver has to work with the clutch and shift gears very often, especialy in a congested city traffic where drivers have lots of stop and go conditions. An automatic transmission in the Mercedes E-Class W211 with gears in the amount of 7 – speeds transmission is in our opinion better one.
0

Rear doors height

760 > 647 mm
0

Payload

2,444 > 2,190 kg
0

Sill height

571 > 759 mm
0

Front overhang

829 > 1,065 mm
0

Valves

24 > 16
0

Tire profile

45 > 55 %
0

Curb weight

1,865 > 1,644 kg

Renault

15 reasons for Renault Vel Satis 2.0 i 16V Turbo 170KM manual in comparison to Mercedes E-Class W211 Estate S211 5.0 V8 (500) 306HP automatic

Reasons for
112

Average consumption

9.6 > 11.6 l
The Renault Vel Satis uses 17 percent fewer in the mixed cycle in comparison to the Mercedes. The difference at the level of 2 l is not very appreciable. However during a longer period of time it would give a substantial cost reduction.
56

Urban consumption

12.6 > 17.3 l
The Renault Vel Satis burns up 27 % fewer fuel in the city compared with the Mercedes E-Class W211 Estate S211. The difference at the level of 27 % will be quite big in everyday use of vehicle. Additionally, during several years it will bring real and noticeable cost savings. Moreover keep in mind that medium results of the average fuel consumption may be considerably lifted if you move dynamically. The difference in fuel economy of the vehicles compared by you is so tremendous that you should consider to choose vehicles with engines of similar power and similar dimensions. Only then will the comparision have a sense.
24

Extra-urban consumption

7.6 > 8.2 l
22

Width

1,858 > 1,817 mm
The width of the vehicle influences directly on passanger's inner room as well as stability of driving. The Renault Vel Satis is 2 percent wider than the Mercedes. It is often clearly perceptible by those sitting in front, who have more room for their elbows.
19

Range

851 > 603 km
19

Fuel tank

81 > 71 l
The winner of this comparison in the category of fuel tank size is Renault Vel Satis that is able to carry by 14 % more fuel compared with the Mercedes E-Class W211.
12

Urban range

635 > 405 km
11

Extra-urban range

1,053 > 833 km
6

Length

4,860 > 4,850 mm
The Renault Vel Satis is 10 mm longer when compared to the Mercedes. Long vehicles are more spacious and also provide bigger trunk. Although the Renault Vel Satis occurs to be better for families or persons who love the idea of soft, smooth long-distance rides, the Mercedes may appeal to women because it will not make troubles with parking and will have smaller turning radius.
1

Height

1,577 > 1,496 mm
The higher a vehicle is, the the more convenient is a boarding it and greater capacity of putting massive amount of luggage to it. The difference between these two cars of 5 % in favor of the Renault Vel Satis is small and does not matter much.
0

Maximal power RPM

5,000 > 5,600 revolutions/minute
0

Front track

1,572 > 1,559 mm
0

Valves per cylinder

4 > 3
0

Width with outside mirrors

2,181 > 1,987 mm
0

Rear overhang

953 > 1,167 mm

Cars specifications

Mercedes E-Class W211 Estate S211 5.0 V8 (500) 306HP automatic Renault Vel Satis 2.0 i 16V Turbo 170HP manual
    Gross trailer weight 2,100 kg -
    Price range luxury popular
    Model release date 2002 2002
    Facelifting no no
    Code name W211 -
By using this site, you agree to the storage and use of cookie files. OK