Seat Alhambra II 1.4 TSI 150HP manual vs Renault Espace III Grand 3.0 V6 194HP automatic

Seat Alhambra II 1.4 TSI 150HP manual

Source: wikipedia.org Charles01 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0

17 reasons for

Seat Alhambra II, model available from 2010.
It has 1.4 TSI 150HP petrol engine produced from 2010.
Drive on the front axle has manual, 6 speed gearbox.

15 reasons for

Renault Espace III Grand, model available from 1996 to 2002.
It has 3.0 V6 194HP ic petrol engine produced from 1998 to 2002.
Drive on the front axle has automatic, 4 speed gearbox.

Renault Espace III Grand 3.0 V6 194HP automatic
Seat

17 reasons for Seat Alhambra II 1.4 TSI 150KM manual in comparison to Renault Espace III Grand 3.0 V6 194HP automatic

Reasons for
112

Average consumption

7 > 11.8 l
The fuel economy is considerably to Seat's advantage. This automobile uses 4.8 l less gasoline in the mixed cycle when compared with the Renault Espace III Grand 3.0 V6 194HP automatic. It is also worth to know that average fuel consumption in the mixed cycle for the van class, in which the Seat Alhambra II 1.4 TSI 150HP manual is classified, is 8.7 l while the Seat Alhambra II uses by 20 % less amount of fuel than the average.
56

Urban consumption

9 > 16.3 l
The Seat Alhambra II burns up 7.3 l of gasoline less in city traffic compared to the Renault Espace III Grand 3.0 V6 194HP automatic. The Seat, which comes from van segment, burns up 2.5 l fewer gasoline, which is by 22 percent better fuel consumption in comparison to the average in its segment. The difference in this category between these two cars is quite significant, so note that in order to the the comparison have a sense, you should pick up models of similar characteristics.
30

Maximal torque RPM

1,500 > 4,000 revolutions/minute
A big difference in rotations per minute at which the maximum torque is generated clearly indicates that the winner is is the one of the Seat Alhambra II 1.4 TSI 150HP manual. The engine of the Renault achieves its full efficiency at 4,000 revolutions per minute which is by 2,500 revolutions per minute worst result than the Seat Alhambra II.
24

Extra-urban consumption

6.1 > 8.9 l
22

Width

1,901 > 1,810 mm
distance between left and right side of a car directly influences on the amount of space for passengers and also stability during driving. The Seat Alhambra II 1.4 TSI 150HP manual is widther only by 91 millimeters in comparison to the Renault Espace III and is not really relevant. The medium for the „van” class equals to approximately 1,821 millimeters and is by 4 % larger than the same feature of the Seat Alhambra II 1.4 TSI 150HP manual.
19

Range

972 > 672 km
15

Wheelbase

2,925 > 2,871 mm
The Seat Alhambra II 1.4 TSI 150HP manual has 2 % longer wheelbase in relation to Renault. Therefore the Seat is more safe and has a better stability. Besides, longer wheelbase has impact on convenient and more comfortable traveling.
12

Urban range

761 > 479 km
11

Extra-urban range

1,148 > 876 km
10

Number of gears

6 > 4 gears
The Seat have a higher speed count compared with the Renault which means that Seat Alhambra II will achieve better acceleration and better fuel economy. But the difference is quiet little and unless you are drag racer at a timed event you would not feel the difference.
6

Length

4,854 > 4,787 mm
The Seat Alhambra II 1.4 TSI 150HP manual is 67 mm longer than the Renault Espace III. Long vehicles are more spacious and usually provide bigger trunk. Although the Seat Alhambra II occurs to be better pick for families or persons who love the idea of convenient rides that make them feel fresh and relaxed upon arriving, the Renault Espace III Grand 3.0 V6 194HP automatic may be more appropriate to the young because it will not make troubles with parking and will have smaller turning radius.
4

Rear track

1,617 > 1,542 mm
1

Height

1,720 > 1,691 mm
The higher a car is, the the more convenient is a getting in to it and greater possibility of putting big amount of thinks to it. The difference of 2 % in favor of the Seat Alhambra II 1.4 TSI 150HP manual is small and does not matter much.
1

Model release date

2010 > 1996
0

Front track

1,571 > 1,534 mm
0

Width with outside mirrors

2,078 > 2,069 mm
0

Curb weight

1,725 > 1,693 kg

Renault

15 reasons for Renault Espace III Grand 3.0 V6 194KM automat in comparison to Seat Alhambra II 1.4 TSI 150HP manual

Reasons for
135

Maximal power

194 > 150 hp
The Renault Espace III Grand has 44 hp more horsepower in comparison to Seat Alhambra II 1.4 TSI 150HP manual. The Renault Espace III Grand will be distinctly quicker speed up because of grater horsepower. Also passing other vehicles while driving should be much more easier for the Renault Espace III Grand 3.0 V6 194HP automatic equipped with more powerful engine.
59

Maximal torque

267 > 240 Nm
The Renault Espace III Grand has 11 percent more torque when compared to the Seat. Even though a great deal of drivers do not take into consideration the maximum torque when buying a automobile, it describes the best how fast a vehicle acclerates. In this case the difference is quite small and for that reason you probably will not feel the difference.
50

Acceleration 0-100 km/h

10.6 > 10.7 s
A small difference in the amount of 1 percent suggests that the Seat Alhambra II 1.4 TSI 150HP manual is slightly beaten here. In the „van” class, to which the Seat Alhambra II is assigned, the medium acceleration is 12.6 s and is by 1.9 s slower than acceleration of Seat’s car.
38

Trunk capacity

520 > 267 l
The trunk of the Renault is 253 liters larger compared to the Seat Alhambra II 1.4 TSI 150HP manual. It is perceptible difference so, in this category the Renault Espace III Grand will be much more functional. The larger the boot, the more baggage you can transport.
33

Trunk capacity with seats down

3,098 > 1,165 l
33

Top speed

206 > 197 km/h
The maximum velocity possible to be reached by the ​​Renault Espace III Grand is greater in relation to of the Seat by 5, which allows the Renault Espace III Grand 3.0 V6 194HP automatic to overcome quicker large distance of highway. The difference at the level of 5 % is small and will be insignificant in everyday driving.
19

Fuel tank

79 > 70 l
The Seat Alhambra II gives way to the Renault in the field of fuel tank capacity. The Renault is able to store by 13 percent more fuel than its competitor.
14

Cylinders

6 > 4
8

Engine capacity

2,947 > 1,391 cc
The Renault Espace III Grand 3.0 V6 194HP automatic has 1,556 cubic centimeters greater engine capacity in comparison to the Seat Alhambra II. Such a substantial difference makes that comparision of this features is hard. The Seat Alhambra II 1.4 TSI 150HP manual would be the right choice for those who apreciate lower fuel consumption and car operating costs at the expense of car’s performance, however, drivers the Renault should take adventage of better power, flexibility, smoothness of the engine and as a result more fun from driving.
8

Maximum load capacity

815 > 567 kg
4

Cylinder layout

V-type > inline
A Vee engine is a upgraded construction of a engine with all cylinders aligned in one row which according to us is with more adventages. Engine of V configuration installed in a vehicle the Renault produces more torque at lower RPM ranges due to the power stroke coming from 2 sides of the crankshaft. This type of engime can contain more cylinders without significant growth in its size. A Smooth engine work and pleasant sound is undoubtedly to a V engine’s advantage.
0

Transmission

automatic > manual
A stick shift with which the Seat Alhambra II is equipped is less complex built and is cheaper in use, however, also it is less comfortable because there is no need to operate clutch to shift gears very often, especialy in a in rush hour in city traffic where drivers have lots of stop and go conditions. An automatic gearbox which is in the Renault Espace III with gears in the amount of 4 – speeds transmission is in our opinion better choice.
0

Maximal power RPM

5,750 > 5,800 revolutions/minute
0

Payload

2,509 > 2,290 kg
0

Valves

24 > 16

Cars specifications

Seat Alhambra II 1.4 TSI 150HP manual Renault Espace III Grand 3.0 V6 194HP automatic
    Gross trailer weight 1,802 kg -
    Price range popular popular
    Model release date 2010 1996
    Facelifting no no
    Class van van
By using this site, you agree to the storage and use of cookie files. OK